This Weeks Makings.

Thanksgiving is a week from today. The doorbell starts around two, and for the next hour you're taking coats, finding room for someone's green bean casserole, and checking the oven.

That's the wrong hour to be shaking cocktails one at a time.

So this year, make a bowl. Fish House Punch is rum, cognac, peach, lemon, and black tea, poured over one big block of ice. You mix it in the morning, set it out, and people help themselves. It's been a Philadelphia party drink for more than two hundred years, and it holds up in the bowl all afternoon.

In this week's newsletter:

  • Fish House Punch, mixed in the morning and poured all afternoon

  • How to build a punch for a crowd, and why one big block of ice beats a bag of cubes

  • Two bonus cocktails, one gin and one rye

  • A trivia question about the Philadelphia club behind the punch

  • A zero proof punch with tea, peach, and lemon

Trivia Question❓

The Philadelphia fishing club tied to Fish House Punch first organized in what year?

A) 1682

B) 1732

C) 1794

D) 1848

Answer at the bottom of the newsletter

Fish House Punch

Rum, cognac, and peach, stretched with lemon and black tea and poured over a block of ice. Bright, a little fruity, and stronger than it tastes.

Ingredients (serves 12, about 4.5 oz each)

  • 12 oz (1 1/2 cups) aged Jamaican rum or gold rum

  • 12 oz (1 1/2 cups) cognac or another good brandy

  • 8 oz (1 cup) peach liqueur, such as crème de pêche

  • 12 oz (1 1/2 cups) strong black tea, cooled

  • 6 oz (3/4 cup) fresh lemon juice, from about 5 lemons

  • 4 oz (1/2 cup) rich simple syrup (2 parts sugar to 1 part water)

  • 1 large block of ice

  • Lemon wheels and a whole nutmeg to garnish

Directions

  1. The night before, fill a loaf pan or bundt pan with water and freeze it

  2. Make the syrup. Stir 1 cup sugar into 1/2 cup hot water until it dissolves, then let it cool. You'll have a little extra

  3. Brew the tea. Steep 4 black tea bags in 1 1/2 cups boiling water for 5 minutes, take out the bags, and let it cool

  4. Add the rum, cognac, peach liqueur, tea, lemon juice, and syrup to a large pitcher. Stir and taste. If it's too tart, add more syrup a little at a time

  5. Cover and chill in the fridge for at least 2 hours and up to 8

  6. When guests arrive, run warm water over the bottom of the pan to loosen the ice. Set the block in a punch bowl and pour the punch over it

  7. Float the lemon wheels on top and grate a little nutmeg over the bowl. Ladle about 4 oz into small glasses or punch cups

Why It Works
Every part has a job. Rum and cognac bring the strength. Lemon and sugar keep it bright. Black tea adds a dry, slightly grippy finish, so a bowl this size doesn't taste like juice. The ice block melts slowly and adds water a little at a time, so the last glass tastes close to the first. This is Difford's Guide's single-glass recipe scaled up for a bowl (the single-glass recipe is here).

Peach liqueur is a modern stand-in for the barrel-aged peach brandy the old recipes used. If you find a dry peach brandy, use it and add a little more syrup.

The punch is tied to a fishing and social club that organized near Philadelphia in 1732 as the Colony in Schuylkill. It still exists, and members still call it the Fish House. The Library of Congress shared a version printed in a 1906 cookbook that called for 2 quarts of Jamaica rum, 1 quart of brandy, 1 quart of lemon juice, a gill of peach brandy, and a 10-pound block of ice (the 1906 recipe is here). Nobody knows when the punch was first made. Drinks historian David Wondrich dates the first written reference to 1794. Another story credits a Philadelphian named Shippen Willing in 1848, and some think the original had no peach at all (the history is here).

Behind the Bar - Punch for a Crowd

A punch is a cocktail you make once. Mix it ahead, set it out, and you get to sit down.

There's an old rhyme for the proportions: one of sour, two of sweet, three of strong, four of weak (the rhyme is here). Sour is citrus. Sweet is sugar or syrup. Strong is the spirit. Weak is water, tea, or juice. Fish House Punch leans stronger than the rhyme, and the ice block does a lot of the weak work as it melts.

How to make punch for a crowd:

  • Freeze a block, not cubes. A loaf pan of ice melts much slower than a bag of cubes, so the punch stays cold without going thin.

  • Mix everything except the ice and any bubbles ahead of time, and chill it. Cold punch melts the block slower.

  • Add sparkling water or sparkling wine right before it goes into the bowl. In the pitcher, it goes flat.

  • Taste it after it's cold. Chilled drinks taste less sweet, so check the balance after the fridge, not before.

  • Use small glasses. A 4 oz pour keeps the bowl going longer, and people can always come back.

  • This recipe gives you 12 to 14 pours. Expecting more than 10 people? Double it and use a bigger bowl.

For more lemon flavor, try an oleo saccharum. Peel 4 lemons with a vegetable peeler, toss the peels with the sugar in a bowl, and let it sit for an hour. The sugar pulls the oil out of the peels and turns syrupy. Stir in the hot water to dissolve it, then strain out the peels. Difford's Guide notes this is the traditional way to make Fish House Punch.

The template underneath:

Spirit, citrus, sugar, and something to stretch it, served over big ice. Swap the rum and cognac for bourbon and the tea for apple cider, and you've got a different punch with the same shape.

Red light skincare, 25% off for Black Friday

Make glowing, radiant skin part of your daily routine with the BON CHARGE Red Light Face Mask. Just 10 minutes a day using 630nm red light and 850nm near infrared light. Shop the Black Friday Sale and enjoy 25% off sitewide via the link.

Bonus Cocktails

Two more this week. One gin and one rye, both shaken, for when the bowl runs low.

Last Word

Gin, green Chartreuse, maraschino, and lime in equal parts. Herbal, tart, and sharper than it looks.

Ingredients

  • 0.75 oz London dry gin

  • 0.75 oz green Chartreuse

  • 0.75 oz maraschino liqueur

  • 0.75 oz fresh lime juice

  • Brandied cherry to garnish (optional)

Directions

Add everything to a shaker with ice. Shake for about 12 seconds. Strain into a chilled coupe and drop in the cherry.

Why it works
It was on the menu at the Detroit Athletic Club by 1916, when it cost 35 cents and was the club's most expensive cocktail. Ted Saucier's 1951 book Bottoms Up! says a vaudeville performer named Frank Fogarty brought it to New York, but nobody knows who invented it. It sat forgotten until 2003, when Seattle bartender Murray Stenson found it in Saucier's book and put it on the menu at the Zig Zag Café (the history is here). Equal parts sounds like it would be too sweet. The lime and the Chartreuse's herbs keep it in check. Pour one before dinner for the guest who wants something stiffer than punch.

Ward Eight

Rye, lemon, orange, and a little grenadine. A whiskey sour with a pink blush.

Ingredients

  • 2 oz rye whiskey

  • 0.5 oz fresh lemon juice

  • 0.5 oz fresh orange juice

  • 1 teaspoon grenadine

  • Cocktail cherry to garnish

Directions

Add everything to a shaker with ice. Shake for about 12 seconds. Strain into a chilled coupe and garnish with the cherry.

Why it works
The usual story says it was made in 1898 at Locke-Ober, a Boston restaurant, to celebrate political boss Martin Lomasney's run for the Massachusetts legislature. Boston's Ward 8 gave him his votes. The story has never been proven. During Prohibition the Boston Globe reported the drink may have started at the Quincy House bar instead, and a company trademarked the name Ward 8 back in 1915 (the record is here). The recipe here is the post-Prohibition Locke-Ober version from the same page. Use grenadine made from pomegranate if you can find it. The bright red supermarket kind is mostly corn syrup and food coloring, and you'll taste it.

❝

“There is one day that is ours.”

- O. Henry, Two Thanksgiving Day Gentlemen

Mocktail or Zero Proof Option

The Zero Proof Fish House Punch

Black tea, peach, and lemon over a block of ice. Same bowl, same garnish, no rum.

Ingredients (serves 10 to 12)

  • 24 oz (3 cups) strong black tea, cooled

  • 8 oz (1 cup) peach nectar

  • 6 oz (3/4 cup) fresh lemon juice

  • 3 oz (6 tablespoons) rich simple syrup, plus more to taste

  • 16 oz (2 cups) cold sparkling water

  • 1 large block of ice

  • Lemon wheels and a whole nutmeg to garnish

Directions

Stir the tea, peach nectar, lemon juice, and syrup together in a pitcher and chill for at least 2 hours. Set the ice block in a punch bowl, pour in the punch, and add the sparkling water right before guests arrive. Float the lemon wheels and grate a little nutmeg over the top.

The tea gives it the dry backbone the rum and cognac usually bring, so it tastes like a drink for adults and not sweet tea. Set it next to the real bowl with a small card so nobody grabs the wrong ladle.

💡 Answer to Trivia Question:

B) 1732.

The club first organized in 1732 as the Colony in Schuylkill, near Philadelphia. It still meets, and members still call it the Fish House (the club's history is here). It also declared itself a sovereign state, and today it goes by the State in Schuylkill (more here). The other years have their own stories. 1794 is the first written mention of the punch that historian David Wondrich has found, and 1848 is the year in the competing Shippen Willing story (those dates are here).

🏁 Closing Time

Thanksgiving is a week from today, and the doorbell will start around two.

Freeze the ice block Wednesday night. Mix the punch Thursday morning before the turkey goes in, and set the bowl out when the first coat comes off. Then go sit down with your people.

Until next week,

Andrea

This Plant-Derived Sleep Support is On Sale Now

If you’re one of the one-in-three adults who don’t get enough sleep, CBD can help. CBD works with your body to support sleep without causing next-morning drowsiness.  

And one of the most-trusted brands for CBD, CBDistillery, isn’t waiting for Black Friday! Our readers can take 30% off with code BF30.

*Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from qualifying purchases. This means that if you click on an Amazon link in this email and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. Your support helps me continue creating quality content and sharing mixology tips. Thank you!

This content is intended for readers of legal drinking age and is for entertainment and educational purposes only. Please drink responsibly.